Cielo
Your furnace is your winter warrior, fighting off the chill by effectively circulating hot air in your home. It operates by using natural gas, propane, or electricity to produce heat. Among the various types of furnaces out there, the single-stage and two-stage models are the most popular choices. Whether you are replacing your old furnace or installing a new one, understanding the distinctions between these types is highly important.
This single-stage vs. two-stage furnace guide dives into the pros and cons of each unit, comparing their power levels, efficiency, and cost to help you find the perfect match for your heating needs.
What is a Single-Stage Furnace?
Single-stage furnaces are the conventional type of furnaces. They operate at full capacity whenever they are turned on, functioning essentially like an on/off switch with only one setting. This can result in temperature fluctuations and energy wastage since they don’t modulate their output based on the actual heating needs of the space. However, it’s a cost-effective option and the most prevalent type of furnace found in homes. Older houses are mostly equipped with single-stage furnaces.
Next-gen smart thermostat for HVAC systems. Achieve the perfect balance between comfort & savings.
Budget-friendly smart thermostat for central HVAC systems. A thermostat that guarantees savings.
Award-winning thermostat for room air conditioners. Technology that goes above & beyond.
The Ultimate smart thermostat for mini-split, window & portable units. Powerful features, more control.
Sleekest smart thermostat for mini-split, window & portable ACs. A design that magically blends.
Smart mini-split thermostat that is engineered for affordable comfort. Small in size, big in benefits.
Pros
- Low initial cost: These furnaces are inexpensive to purchase and install. They cost about $2000 to $3500, including the installation charges.
- Cheaper repairs and maintenance: A single-stage furnace’s repairs are more economical due to its simpler construction and fewer intricate components.
- Great for short-term heating solution: If you are in need of a furnace replacement and also anticipate moving soon, a single-stage furnace will be less costly to purchase. Plus, you won’t be in your current home long enough to reap the energy-saving benefits that a two-stage furnace offers.
Cons
- Uneven heat distribution: The single-stage furnace rapidly blasts a large amount of hot air, and this results in areas close to the vents heating up more quickly. Your thermostat concludes that the entire home has achieved the set temperature, leading to an early shutdown of the furnace. Consequently, this can create areas that are unevenly heated, with some spots being warmer and others cooler.
Related: Top Ways You Can Fix Hot & Cold Spots And Maintain Even Temperature
- Noisy operation: Because of its frequent on-and-off cycles, this furnace makes more noise when operating.
- High energy usage: Since the furnace operates at maximum capacity each time it’s turned on, it ends up using a significant amount of energy.
Equip your HVAC system with smart features and achieve the perfect balance between comfort & savings.
Shop Now
What is a Two-Stage Furnace?
These furnaces offer a more sophisticated heating approach with two operating modes: low and high. This allows them to adjust heat output according to your heating needs, ensuring a more consistent and comfortable indoor environment.
In moderate climate, the two-stage furnace works at the lower setting, saving energy and reducing heating bills while maintaining a pleasant house temperature.
When the temperature plummets, the furnace switches to its higher setting, providing increased heating power to maintain indoor comfort. This ensures warmth even during extreme cold spells. It returns to low power when conditions change. Interestingly, you can also adjust your two-stage furnace to an in-between setting.
Pros
- Uniform heat distribution and enhanced comfort: The gradual adjustment from low to high output avoids the abrupt bursts of hot air typical of single-stage furnaces, leading to an even heat distribution and a pleasant indoor atmosphere.
- Improved efficiency: A two-stage furnace adjusts to your home’s varying heating requirements. It primarily operates at 60% to 65% capacity, consuming less fuel and therefore costing less money compared to a single-stage furnace.
- Longer lifespan: As a two-stage furnace doesn’t operate at full capacity, it experiences less strain, which can extend its lifespan.
- Quiet operation: The two-stage furnace makes less noise than single-stage models. Its lower setting ensures a quieter environment.
- Improved indoor air quality: Enhances the air quality by effectively trapping pet dander, pollen, mold spores, and other indoor air pollutants, thus fostering a healthier environment.
Cons
- High initial cost: A dual-stage furnace requires an investment of several hundred dollars higher than single-stage models. If you don’t intend to reside in your current home for an extended period, the additional expense may not justify the initial cost.
- Complex maintenance: Finding and replacing parts can be challenging, resulting in costly and time-consuming repairs.
Differences Between Single-Stage vs. Two-Stage Furnaces
Aside from the obvious variances in their power levels, other comparisons drawn between one-stage vs. two-stage furnaces are:
| Single-Stage Furnace | Two-Stage Furnace |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
-
Cost
When considering the cost aspect, single-stage furnaces emerge as a budget-friendly option. They cost around $700 and $3,000. On the other hand, two-stage furnaces entail a higher initial investment, costing between $1,000 and $3,500.
Despite the high initial price, a two-stage or dual-fuel furnace boasts remarkable energy efficiency benefits in the long run. Optimizing energy usage significantly reduces operational expenses.
However, if you are looking to install a furnace in a rental home and will have to relocate after some time, a single-stage furnace is a more cost-effective short-term solution.
-
Efficiency
Single-stage furnaces have a fixed power level and lack the flexibility to make adjustments according to the heating requirements. This fixed operation renders them less efficient compared to two-stage furnaces.
Two-stage furnaces, on the other hand, may vary between high and low power depending on the amount of heat needed. This adaptability maximizes heat production while reducing energy usage.
-
Comfort
Single-stage furnaces are great for heating smaller homes and apartments. However, they may encounter challenges in adequately heating larger, multi-story properties. In such cases, rooms closer to the warm air vents might reach desired temperatures faster than those farther away, causing the furnace to mistakenly believe the entire house is sufficiently warm. Consequently, the furnace may shut off prematurely, resulting in hot and cold spots.
Two-stage furnaces, on the other hand, automatically adapt to avoid temperature variations, resulting in even heating and increased comfort.
-
Maintenance
Single-stage and two-stage furnaces differ significantly in terms of maintenance. Single-stage furnaces, which have fewer components, are easier to clean and maintain. Two-stage furnaces, on the other hand, are more complex and require professional tune-ups. Here’s all you need to know about furnace maintenance.
Two-stage furnaces are notably more efficient than single-stage furnaces, which reduces the system’s strain. On the other hand, single-stage units constantly operate at a high energy output. Over time, this continuous high-level operation can lead to wear and tear, necessitating costly repairs for these units.
Should You Choose a Single-Stage or Two-Stage Furnace?
The choice between a single-stage vs. two-stage furnace is determined by the size of your home, local climate conditions, and your own personal preferences.
When to Choose a Single-Stage Furnace?
- If budget constraints are a concern, and you can’t pay for a higher upfront cost.
- Your area experiences mild winters with less demand for heating.
- Your home is either single-level or an older construction.
When to Choose a Two-Stage Furnace?
- If you are looking to upgrade your heating to an efficient system, then you should invest in a two-stage furnace.
- You have a multiple-story home where a single-stage furnace won’t work effectively.
- If you live in an area that experiences harsh climates, then consider getting this type of furnace for enhanced comfort.
In Conclusion
A single-stage furnace runs at a constant power level, operating at full capacity until it reaches the desired temperature. A two-stage furnace, on the other hand, can run at two capacity levels, a low and a high level, which allows for greater efficiency in maintaining an ideal temperature.
When making the final decision, compare the pros and cons of a single-stage furnace vs. a two-stage furnace. Also, take into account factors such as your budget, climatic conditions, and your house levels. If you can’t pay a higher upfront cost and you are living in a short-term rental, then a single-stage furnace makes more sense. However, for a multiple-story house where inconsistent heating of a single-stage furnace becomes an issue, a two-stage furnace is a great alternative. Also, the dual-stage furnace works best in regions where temperatures drop below freezing as compared to single-stage furnaces.
